[MUSIC] Welcome back. I enjoyed our last quiz in which you and I had a chance to choose a work of modern art or one of modern music. And most of you chose the art. And we tried to explain why. But let's have another quiz, now, choosing just between two pieces of music. Let's say, you're stranded on a beautiful desert island but have only one piece, only one piece of music to listen to in perpetuity. Time immemorial. Which piece would you choose? Piece one or piece two? Here's piece one. [MUSIC] And now piece two. [MUSIC] Well, I would submit that most of us would choose piece one. Piece two seems a little unnatural for reasons that we'll get into later. Piece one was by Mozart. Piece two by Arnold Schoenberg. Who was this seminal figure to whom I keep referencing or referring? Who was Arnold Schoenberg? Well, Schoenberg was born in Vienna, and was essentially self-taught in music. In the 1920s, Schoenberg moved to Berlin. And then in the 1930s, when the Nazis took over Germany and Austria, he, as with so many other Jews and artists and intellectuals, fled and came to the United States. Indeed, Schoenberg settled and ultimately died in Los Angeles, in 1951. And the Schoenberg family is still prominent in Los Angeles, in legal circles, legal profession today, having played a role in the infamous OJ Simpson trial. Small world. Anyway, as a young man, Schoenberg wasn't sure if he was going to be a musician or a painter. As you can see, he was skilled in painting in the expressionist style of art, as practiced in Vienna and Munich and Berlin, around this time, around 1910. Actually, the prototype of expressionist art might be the creation of Norwegian artist Edvard Munch and his famous, The Scream. You can see the similarities to Schoenberg's art here. German or Nordic expressionism is very different from French impressionism. With impressionism, it's the receiver, the viewer, who fashions the ultimate effect of the painting in his or her own mind. With expressionism, it's the artist alone attempting not to create a scene or mood of some external subject or object, but rather the mood of the artist exporting the inner feelings of the artist. Expressionist art is full of anxiety, fear, intensity, angst, as the Germans would say. And we've got plenty of angst in Schoenberg's iconic work of musical expressionism Pierrot Lunaire. Premiered in 1912, Pierrot Lunaire is Schoenberg's setting of 21 poems by poet Albert Giraud. Pierrot is a clown, a clown from traditional italian puppet and carnival shows, Commedia dell'Arte. But here, Pierrot is not just any clown, but a sad clown. And a clown who is slightly crazy, indeed loony. A clown who has, like the werewolf, come under the spell of the full moon, la lune, in French. Loony. So, this clown borders on the hysterical. Schoenberg's music will sound a bit hysterical, too. This is atonal music, music without a tonal center. If we take scales away, as we know them, and take away triads and take away functional chord progressions, we end up with music without a key. Music without a tonal center. Atonal music. This feeling of disruption, disjunction is affected by something called octave displacement, which destroys a sense of melody as we know it. Or perhaps, challenges us to hear melody in a new way. Let me play a tune. Can you identify this tune? So let me play this for you. [MUSIC] Okay, let's do it again. [MUSIC] Can you hear that? Yeah, that really was. [MUSIC] Something as simple as Mary Had A Little Lamb. But each of the pitches was taken and removed, was displaced an octave from one another. And that's what makes this music hard to recognize, hard to understand. Here, we see a passage through Pierrot Lunaire as Schoenberg wrote it on the left, and as he might have written it. He could have written it if he wanted to, to make it more readily understandable. So let me see if I can duplicate this on the screen here. Here's what Schoenberg wrote. [MUSIC] And here's what we probably would have preferred to hear. [MUSIC] And finally, the sense of disjunction and hysteria is magnified here by a new kind of vocal delivery that Schoenberg created, called Sprechstimme, speech/song. Something that's neither speech nor song, but halfway between the two. The little X's that you see on the notes here are Schoenberg's signs or commands to use Sprechstimme. Okay, let's focus now on song number six of Pierrot Lunaire, Madonna. Here's the full text. Our hysterical clown has a vision of the mother of Christ, Madonna, at the cross, gazing upon her crucified son. She is expressing her inner feelings at this excruciating moment. Notice that the text here refers to her eyes as rot und offen. Surely, the line in the text caused Schoenberg to create this sort of music here. But also, to recreate it in his painting at about the same time, Red Gaze, of 1910. So we have the hallucination of the clown gazing upon Mary at the cross who looks down at us with eyes red and open. Did we realize that the human in the red gaze is a female? Perhaps that's why Schoenberg created this setting of songs, created Pierrot Lunaire for female voice. Let's listen to unique approach to text and music. [MUSIC] And now, an instrumental interlude. [MUSIC] The text continues. [MUSIC] Did you like that last chord? When Arnold Schoenberg created atonal music such as this, he entered a brave new land. But it was a lawless land, there were no rules. In tonal music, we knew that this set of pitches was to be followed by this set of pitches, and then onto this next set of pitches. There was a hierarchy. Sub-dominant chord would go to the dominant chord, and that would then move on to the final tonic chord. Now, with atonal music, there is no hierarchy. And all 12 pitches are equal. But if all 12 pitches are equal, why choose any one pitch at any given time? The composer had absolute freedom. But as Igor Stravinsky observed in his poetics of music, nothing, nothing is more frightening for the creator and maybe for every individual. Nothing is more frightening than absolute freedom. At least with tonal music, the composer had a template of tried and true tonal chord progressions and tried and true musical forms. So Schoenberg had created a conundrum of sorts. [LAUGH] He was a prisoner of absolute freedom. How did he solve the problem? He invented a new system of rules, and thereby created 12-tone music.